Iron Toxicity
By Dr. Paul C. Eck
and
Dr. Larry Wilson

2225 W. Alice Avenue - Phoenix, Arizona 85021 USA 1-602-995-1580
This material is for educational purposes only
The preceding statements have not been evaluated by the
Food and Drug Administration
This information is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any
disease.
Copyright © 1989 - The Eck Institute of Applied Nutrition and
Bioenergetics, Ltd.
Introduction
We all know iron as an essential mineral, one that is often
supplemented to make sure we are obtaining enough of this vital element. Less
known is that iron can be toxic and that iron toxicity is not as rare as might
be imagined.
In fact, iron toxicity is often overlooked in the fervor to
correct anemia and fatigue by automatically giving iron pills. Because of the
seriousness of iron toxicity and the folklore that everyone needs iron,
it is important to address iron toxicity.
There are two primary types of iron toxicity, inherited or
congenital and acquired iron toxicity. This paper focuses on acquired iron
toxicity and its correction. However, it is important to say a few words about
inherited hemochromatosis.
Recently, the First International Conference on
Hemochromatosis was held at the New York Academy of Sciences. Dr. H. Ralph
Schumacher, Jr. stated that many patients with iron poisoning are incorrectly
diagnosed. For example, of 129 patients with arthritis-like symptoms due to iron
toxicity, only 16 were correctly diagnosed.
The prevalence of inherited hemochromatosis, once thought to
be 1 in 20,000 is actually between 3 and 6 in 1000. The gene frequency of
hemochromatosis is actually higher than that of any other known genetic
disorder!
In addition to the inherited disorder, acquired iron toxicity
is quite prevalent and occurs insidiously. Iron overload from a variety of
sources can contribute to a wide range of diseases from heart failure and
diabetes to thyroid and liver disease.
Those most susceptible to iron toxicity are men, and people
exposed to high levels of iron in their food, water or occupations.
Sources Of Iron
Food Sources
Iron is well absorbed from animal products, especially meats.
Excellent sources include shellfish, liver and other organ meats. Iron in egg
yolks is not well absorbed, although having orange juice with your eggs will
increase the absorption of iron from the egg yolk.
Iron is abundant in some vegetables, but is generally less
well absorbed because of the presence of phytates, oxalates, tannin and other
substances that interfere with iron absorption. Vegetables high in iron include
green leafy vegetables such as kale, collard, mustard greens, Swiss chard and
spinach.
In addition, legumes, beets, black cherries, and molasses are
good sources. Dried fruits, seeds, nuts, yeast, wheat germ, whole-grain cereals
and breads also contain significant amounts of iron. Beer and red wine contain
iron, and alcohol ingested along with iron enhances iron absorption, which may
result in iron-storage diseases.
Cookware
Foods cooked in iron cookware will pick up iron from the
skillet or pan. Tomato products such as spaghetti sauce and apple butter, are
most likely to leach iron from pots because of the acidic nature of these foods.
Iron Pipes
Some communities have iron water pipes. Iron can be leached
from pipes, especially if the water is acidic. Iron pipes are also subject to
rusting, allowing iron oxide flakes to be added to the water.
Drinking Water Supplies
Iron is a common water contaminant in certain areas of the
country. Often the soil has a reddish color, and a brownish ring is present in
bathtubs and on plumbing fixtures. Drinking water can be an important source of
iron toxicity.
Occupational Exposure
Welders, sheet metal workers, machinists, plumbers, auto
mechanics, steel workers and other workers exposed to iron and steel can absorb
large quantities of iron through contact.
Food Supplements
Many commonly prescribed vitamin and mineral preparations
contain large quantities of iron. Long-term consumption of these products,
prescribed by a physician or self-prescribed, can cause iron overload. However,
many iron supplements are poorly absorbed.
Bread, Cereals and Other White Flour Products
Federal law requires that white flour and refined cereal
products labeled enriched must have 25 mg. iron added per pound of flour.
The form of iron used, however, is not particularly well absorbed.
Other Sources
Repeated blood transfusions, and use of galvanized iron
containers can be sources of iron. Hemolytic anemia and aplastic anemia can
cause iron toxicity by enhancing iron absorption. Early acute hepatitis can
contribute to iron toxicity by interfering with iron excretion.
Detection Of Iron Toxicity
Detection of iron toxicity is often based on suspicion due to
joint pain, amenorrhea, or sudden onset of shortness of breath. A liver biopsy
or other organ biopsy will confirm hemochromatosis. Elevated serum ferritin
above 1000 nv/ml is also used to diagnose iron toxicity.
Hair Analysis
Hair analysis can be helpful to detect iron toxicity.
However, some skill in interpretation is necessary. High iron on a hair test may
represent an iron loss due to protein catabolism and release of iron from cells.
This is often the case when iron is elevated and the sodium/potassium ratio in
an unwashed hair sample is less than 2.0:1.2
Also, an iron toxicity problem may not be revealed on the
first tissue mineral analysis test. Iron that is stored in the liver or other
body tissues may require several months to a year or more before it is mobilized
from the tissues and revealed on the test.
Metabolism Of Iron
Absorption
Iron is poorly absorbed by the body. It is estimated that
only about 10-15% of ingested iron is absorbed, although the percentage is
higher if an iron deficiency is present.
Synergists
Iron absorption is enhanced by the amino acids histidine,
lysine and vitamin C, vitamin E, citric acid, lactose, fructose, glucose,
sucrose, and sorbitol.
Ingestion of acidic foods such as; alcohol and animal
proteins, enhances iron absorption. States of anemia, B6 deficiency, iron
deficiency and hypoxia also enhance iron absorption.
Antagonists
Manganese, copper, zinc, cobalt, nickel, chromium, calcium,
magnesium, and cadmium compete with iron for absorption. Phosphates, egg
proteins, long-chain fatty acids and phytates found in cereals interfere with
iron absorption.
Old age, copper deficiency, achlorhydria, tea, oxalic acid,
soy protein, antacids, and vegetarian diets are associated with reduced iron
absorption.
Chelated iron supplements (citrate, lactate, fumarate,
gluconate, succinate, and glycinate) are better absorbed than the commonly used
iron sulfate. The iron often used to fortify flour and cereal products is very
poorly absorbed.
Retention
About 75% of the iron in an adult is found in hemoglobin,
myoglobin and iron-containing enzymes such as catalase and peroxidase enzymes.
The other 25% is stored in the liver, spleen and bone marrow.
Excretion
Normally, 95-100% of iron is retained by the body. This is a
common reason why iron toxicity occurs. Iron is normally excreted in the bile,
but is reabsorbed in the intestines. The body does not seem to have specific
excretory mechanisms for iron. Kidney involvement in iron excretion is
negligible. Menstruation is the most common cause of iron loss.
Metabolic Effects Of Iron Toxicity
Deposition in Body Organs and Tissues
The detrimental effects of chronic iron toxicity are due in
part to iron accumulation in various organs. These include the heart, liver,
brain, pancreas, and joints.
Displacement of Vital Nutrients
Many of the symptoms of iron toxicity are due to displacement
by iron of zinc, copper, manganese and other vital nutrients.
Psychological Effects of Iron
Iron toxicity is commonly associated with personality
characteristics of a strong ego, rigidity, tenaciousness, hostility stubbornness
and irritability. Lou Gehrig was known as "the iron man of baseball" because he
set a record for the number of consecutive games played. He died at an early age
of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. Even when he was seriously ill, he continued
to play baseball for the New York Yankees.
The iron personality may be due to the action of iron
in increasing the adrenal hormone, aldosterone. Aldosterone serves to increase
the sodium level, which in turn, is associated with increased volatility of
temperament. Higher sodium levels also tend to lower calcium, magnesium, and
zinc levels, which can increase irritability.
Iron also deposits in the amygdala, a portion of the brain
associated with feelings of anger and hostility. Another possible mechanism is
that iron toxicity has been associated with increased levels of plasma histamine
and serotonin.
Metabolic Dysfunctions Associated With Iron
Toxicity
Aging, Premature
Iron, in excess, can damage the liver and other organs
leading to premature aging and death.
Anger
Anger may be due to increased sodium levels, or accumulation
of iron in the amygdala of the brain.
Arthritis
Iron can accumulate in the synovial membrane of joints. Iron
also interferes with zinc and copper metabolism, which are needed to maintain
the integrity of the joint surfaces.
Birth Defects
Birth defects may be due to iron-induced zinc deficiency.
Bleeding Gums
Iron can deplete vitamin C, leading to bleeding gums and
periodontal disease. Iron toxicity can also prolong blood clotting time.
Cancer
Iron toxicity can cause liver damage, which may result in
malignancy. Iron toxicity is also associated with excessive protein catabolism;
a condition associated with development of malignancy.
Cardiomyopathies
Iron has an affinity for cardiac tissue and in excess, causes
damage to the heart muscle.
Cirrhosis of the Liver
Iron is normally stored in the liver, and excess iron
accumulation results in liver damage.
Constipation
Iron, in excess, is a frequent cause of constipation.
Diabetes
Excessive iron antagonizes chromium needed for insulin
transport. Iron, in excess, also by causing a zinc deficiency, results in
diabetes. Zinc is needed for insulin production. Iron buildup in the pancreas
results in pancreatic damage.
Diarrhea
Intestinal irritation due to iron supplements can cause
diarrhea.
Dizziness
Dizziness may be due to manganese deficiency caused by
excessive tissue iron. Manganese is required for inner ear function that
controls the sense of balance.
Fatigue
Iron accumulation in the liver and other tissues can result
in extreme fatigue. Iron-induced diabetes can also be a cause of fatigue.
Depletion of essential trace elements such as zinc, copper and manganese can
impair energy production resulting in fatigue.
Grayish-Hued Skin
Extreme iron toxicity results in grayish-hued skin.
Headaches
Iron accumulation, by raising blood pressure in the cerebral
arteries, can cause headaches.
Heart Failure
Iron accumulation in heart tissue can damage the heart muscle
leading to heart failure.
Hemochromatosis (iron deposits in organs)
Excess iron is deposited in the liver, pancreas, brain,
heart, joints and other body tissues leading to impairment of organ function.
Hepatitis
By damaging the liver, iron toxicity can contribute to
hepatitis and other liver disorders.
Hostility
Excessive iron may be associated with hostility by raising
sodium and lowering magnesium and calcium levels. Iron also is deposited in the
amygdala of the brain; a center associated with hostility and anger.
Hyperactivity
Iron raises sodium and lowers calcium, magnesium and zinc
levels. Deficiency of these sedative minerals commonly leads to hyperactivity.
Hypertension
By raising sodium, iron can contribute to water retention,
leading to an abnormal increase in blood pressure. Also, iron toxicity can lower
calcium, magnesium and zinc levels. This results in increased vascular tone,
which in turn can result in hypertension.
Infections
Bacteria require iron to proliferate or multiply. Excessive
tissue iron also lowers copper, a mineral that serves to inhibit bacterial
infection.
Insomnia
Insomnia may be due to iron's ability to lower calcium,
magnesium, and zinc, hence increasing nervousness and irritability.
Liver Disease
One of the principal storage sites for iron is the liver.
Excessive iron can result in damage to the liver (see: also cirrhosis of the
liver).
Mental Problems
Irritability, hostility, anger, nervousness, and
schizophrenia are commonly associated with iron toxicity.
Metallic Taste in Mouth
Liver toxicity and elimination of iron through saliva may
cause a metallic taste in the mouth.
Myasthenia Gravis
Excessive tissue iron, by lowering manganese levels, can, by
interfering with neurotransmitters, result in damage to muscle tissue. This may
result in conditions such as myasthenia gravis.
Nausea
Damage to the liver and pancreas, due to iron deposition, can
produce nausea.
Nevi
Damage to the blood vessels may occur as a result of a
vitamin C, zinc, or copper deficiency, secondary to iron toxicity.
Nervousness and Irritability
Iron raises sodium, which can lower calcium, magnesium and
zinc levels. This frequently leads to nervousness and irritability.
Parkinson's Disease
Iron may contribute to neuromuscular diseases by lowering
copper, zinc, and manganese levels.
Rheumatoid Arthritis
It is common for excess iron to be deposited in the synovial
membranes of the joints, resulting in arthritis. Rigidity is associated with
iron toxicity. (See also arthritis)
Schizophrenia
Iron-induced schizophrenia may be due to the depletion of
zinc from certain areas of the brain.
Scurvy
Iron is known to destroy vitamin C, which in turn, results in
scurvy.
Sickle-Cell Anemia
There is evidence that iron toxicity may be associated with
development of sickle-cell anemia.
Stubbornness
Stubbornness is part of the iron personality and is
perhaps due to an increase in the rate of metabolism and the loss of minerals
such as zinc and copper.
Strabismus (rapid eye movements)
Rapid eye movements have been noted with iron toxicity.
Vitamin and Mineral Deficiencies
Excess iron can deplete vitamin B6 and vitamin C. In
addition, iron toxicity can also cause a deficiency of manganese, zinc and
copper.
Effects Of Iron On Other Minerals And Vitamins
Calcium and Magnesium
Iron toxicity, by raising tissue sodium levels, can cause an increase in the
oxidation rate and a lowering of tissue calcium and magnesium levels.
Sodium
Iron tends to raise tissue sodium levels.
Manganese
Iron competes with manganese for absorption and iron
displaces manganese in the liver and in body tissues. Excessive iron ingestion
can contribute to a manganese deficiency.
Copper
Iron competes with copper for absorption, and displaces
copper from the liver.
Zinc
Iron competes for absorption with zinc.
Chromium
Iron can displace chromium in body tissues.
Vitamin C and B6
Iron toxicity can lower the levels of these vitamins.
Effects Of Other Nutrients On Iron
Manganese, copper, zinc, cobalt, cadmium and nickel
compete with iron for absorption.
Copper and manganese can replace iron in the liver and
other body tissues.
Lead interferes with heme synthesis.
Vitamin C enhances iron absorption.
Vitamin B6 deficiency causes enhanced iron absorption.
Detoxification Of Excessive Iron
Several methods are used for congenital hemochromatosis.
Phlebotomy, or bleeding, is still used. Desferroxamine-B is a chelating agent
that is occasionally used to enhance urinary excretion of iron.
For acquired iron toxicity, we have devised a very effective
nutritional protocol using a combination of approaches. All the following
measures should be done together for optimum results:
| • |
Inhibition of iron absorption is achieved by reducing vitamin C intake and avoiding iron-containing food supplements, iron cookware and other sources of iron. |
| • |
Antagonists such as manganese, copper, zinc, and B6 are given to reduce iron absorption and assist in the removal of iron from the liver and other organs. |
| • |
Reducing protein catabolism is important in many cases. Breakdown of proteins results in a release of iron from damaged cells. Protein catabolism has to be reversed by providing nutrients that enhance energy production and balance the sodium/potassium ratio on the hair analysis. |
| • |
Increase energy levels by balancing
critical mineral ratios, so that energy is available to detoxify
iron. |
| • |
Enhancing the production of ferritin and ceruloplasmin is helpful in mobilizing iron. These iron-binding blood proteins are produced in the liver and require copper and zinc for their manufacture. Adrenal gland activity must also be restored to enhance ceruloplasmin production. |
References
| 1. |
Kutsky, R. J. Ph.D., Handbook of Vitamins, Minerals and Hormones, Second Edition, Van Nostrand Reinhold Co., New York, 1981. |
| 2. |
Linder, M., editor, Nutritional Biochemistry and Metabolism, Elsevier Science Publishing, New York, 1985 |
| 3. |
Passwater, R. & Cranton, E., Trace Elements, Hair Analysis, and Nutrition, Keats Publishing, Inc., New Canaan, Connecticut, 1983. |
| 4. |
Pfeiffer, C., Mental and Elemental Nutrients, Keats Publishing, Inc., New Canaan, Connecticut, 1975. |
| 5. |
Rodale, J.I., editor, Complete Book of Minerals For Health, Rodale Books, Emmaus, Pa. |

Articles
